It just takes one story to spark a legend and claim “paranormal” evidence

Spooky sighting sparks investigation (From Western Telegraph).

Paranormal investigators are to look into spooky sightings of a ghostly child pulling a cart near Carew.

The spooktacular sight was spotted on the A477. The witness told the Western Telegraph: “Has anyone else seen a ghost of a young boy pulling a wooden cart which is too large to be a toy?

“I saw him running across the road very quickly and when I arrived at the point where he would have been, there was no sign of him.

Shaun Sables of Pembrokeshire Beyond said:

“It’s hard for us to say what the cause of this is without more specifics and further description of the sighting, though it may well be paranormal.”

Source: Western Telegraph

Here is how legends are born. Details are scant from this article (from Southwest Wales), but I posted it because it is typical of the stories I see from all over the world that appear in news results for “paranormal”.

I’m disturbed by a few things: these stories are put in the media as NEWS based on usually one eyewitness account, which can’t be confirmed; it results in people deliberately looking for local legends to account for the unconfirmed sighting (post hoc); and that it gives attention and credentials to local amateur paranormal investigation groups who JUMP at the chance to call something “paranormal”.

In a scientific investigation, I can’t conceive of an instance where one would declare something “paranormal”. You could conclude “I don’t know” or “This observation does not have a current explanation” but that is based on what facts are at hand. As we see in this case, all we have is an eyewitness report. I get discouraged when an entire tale is built around one questionable claim and then declare evidence for the paranormal. That is an egregious error in logic.

Comments are tightly moderated. Please follow the Comment Policy.
This is not a forum or free-for-all. Only thoughtful additions and pertinent opinions will be approved.