A curious twist to Indiana Creationism bill that makes it even LESS scientific (if possible)

Legislators on Monday broadened a proposal aimed at allowing Indiana’s public schools to teach creationism in science classes to require that such courses include origin of life theories from multiple religions.

The Senate approved the change to legislation critics had argued was unconstitutional because federal courts repeatedly have found teaching creationism violates church-state separation because of its reliance on the Bible’s book of Genesis.

The change proposed by Democratic Sen. Vi Simpson of Bloomington says any course offered by public schools teaching creationism must include origin theories from multiple religions, among them Christianity, Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism and Scientology.

Simpson said she didn’t think the change would resolve constitutional problems, but she believed broadening the subject matter might cause local school boards to hesitate before deciding to insert religion into science classes.

Credit: @Blue_wode on Twitter

So, picture this: A whole session (or multiple) in science class learning about the 101 creation myths of the world. (Notice they forgot all the native myths from every country around the world. Those were “religions” at one time too.) Talk about a slippery slope. But, it’s good to see. Points out the absurdity with such a plan.

Again, I’ll say that this sounds like a fine idea for a comparative religions class. I would send my child to that in a heartbeat. I want them to hear my favorite one

Odin, the son of Bur’s son Borr, killed Ymir. The blood pouring out of the giant’s body killed all the frost giants Ymir had created, except Bergelmir. From Ymir’s dead body, Odin created the world. Ymir’s blood was the sea; his flesh, the earth; his skull, the sky; his bones, the mountains; his hair, the trees. The new Ymir-based world was Midgard. Ymir’s eyebrow was used to fence in the area where mankind would live. Around Midgard was an ocean where a serpent named Jormungand lived. He was big enough to form a ring around Midgard by putting his tail in his mouth.

UPDATE (2-Feb-2012) Here is a piece about the woman who punk’d the Creationist legislators.

  2 comments for “A curious twist to Indiana Creationism bill that makes it even LESS scientific (if possible)

  1. Massachusetts
    January 31, 2012 at 8:24 PM

    I took this class in college. It was called Intro to Cultural Anthropology. I really enjoyed it. Too bad they can’t teach it to high school kids, before or after they go to their science class.

  2. Massachusetts
    January 31, 2012 at 8:25 PM

    I didn’t realize that scientology was one of the worlds major religions.

Comments are closed.